Trusting sovereign language models as scientific instruments: evidence from Portugal's AMALIA

תקציר מקורי באנגליתarXiv:2607.08731v2 Announce Type: replace Abstract: National language models are becoming publicly funded epistemic infrastructure. Public ownership, linguistic specialization, and open weights create a presumption of trustworthiness. Such an instrument, built by and for a language community, looks like the natural choice for measuring what that community says and values. Whether such a model validly measures anything is untested at release. The evaluation of LLMs as measurement instruments is typically task-specific and stops at agreement with human coders. Agreement cannot distinguish an LLM instrument that measures a construct from one that reaches matching codes through surface correlates. We audit the presumption on a favourable case: AMALIA, Portugal's publicly funded 9B model, codin